Newsweek journalist Daniel Lyons posed a series of questions recently to Bill Gates, a leading and powerful voice in the new school reform movement, and Randi Weingarten, president of the American Federation of Teachers—highlighting not what we need to address in our public schools but proving further that the media, celebrity/billionaire experts, and bureaucrats are themselves incompetent and should not be leading a discussion about education.
Alfie Kohn recently began to unmask the new reformer movement dominating public discourse about education and education reform:
“For a shrewd policy maker, then, the ideal formula would seem to be to let people enjoy the invigorating experience of demanding reform without having to give up whatever they’re used to. And that’s precisely what both liberals and conservatives manage to do: Advertise as a daring departure from the status quo what is actually just a slightly new twist on it.”
Lyons, Gates, and Weingarten—like Secretary of Education Arne Duncan and former DC chancellor Michelle Rhee—are personifying Kohn’s “ideal formula”:
The Newsweek piece, perpetuated in the Education section of The Huffington Post, is flawed from the start, with each question framing the potential answers within misinformation and distortion. As well, we cannot discount that the entire discussion is also framed among the elites themselves—authorities who have benefitted well from the current system, leaving us to wonder why they would want to change anything.
If we can’t change the questions posed by Lyons, we can at least imagine what the answers should have been.
First Question:
“Our schools are lagging behind the rest of the world. Why is that? How did we fall so far behind?”
The Answer We Need:
International comparisons are being distorted—and are a stale mantra of public school detractors reaching back into the 1950s. Consider the relentless bashing of public schools in the mid-twentieth century by Admiral Rickover (comparing the US to the Swiss and British) and the charges that public school students couldn’t read from Rudolph Flesch.
Test scores in each nation have NEVER been shown to be directly or positively correlated with that country’s economy; and, international test comparisons gloss over populations being compared—first, the US has around 21% childhood poverty compared to Finland’s 3-4%, thus the populations are different, not the quality of the schools since about 80-90% of achievement is tied to out-of-school factors.
When we consider poverty in an analysis of PISA scores from 2009 (the source of much hang wringing), the comparisons expose the social inequities tolerated by the US—not the failure of the schools.
And if we find ourselves enamored with Finland because of their high test scores, we must be prepared to accept the full picture of that envy since Finland rejects most of the exact reforms the new reformers are proposing. As well, Finland offers government support for teachers’ advanced degrees, a teacher force that is virtually 100% unionized.
So the short answer is that the US is lagging the world in addressing childhood and overall poverty, and that reality is reflected in our schools—not caused by them.
Second Question:
The Answer We Need:
Teacher quality is only a small percent of achievement, and there is little evidence that teacher quality is the most or even one of the main problems with student achievement in public schools. But the provable problem with teacher quality is teacher assignment. Peske and Haycock (2006) show that students in poverty, students of color, and ELL students are in classrooms with the least experienced teachers who are often un- or under-qualified/certified.
Teacher quality does matter in terms of what happens once students are within the walls of schools, but we seem blind to the long standing tradition of assigning the most experienced and best qualified teachers to the elite students, who are already experiencing advantages in their full lives outside of school.
Third Question:
The Answer We Need:
Finland’s teachers are essentially 100% unionized. In the US, states with the strongest teachers unions correlate positively with the highest test scores (although a shift in what test scores are examined can achieve a different conclusion). That union bashers ignore this data is telling.
Union bashing, like union advocacy, tends to fail because of oversimplification and conflating correlation simplistically with causation.
Fourth Question:
“Should we have a national curriculum in the United States?”
The Answer We Need:
The call for national standards is the exact wolf in sheep’s clothing that Kohn has warned us about—masking the status quo in reform discourse.
Fifth Question:
The Answer We Need:
Tenure is about due process and academic freedom. Let’s start that discussion with accurate information. The tenure mantra is similar to the union mantra from the new reformers. Since they consistently misrepresent their claims—and fail to show evidence to substantiate their claims—we can rest assured that their motives are as specious as their arguments.
Is tenure a concept worth debating? Of course, if we genuinely feel due process and academic freedom are irrelevant to the profession of teaching.
Is there any credible evidence that the tenure debate is essential for addressing the most pressing issues facing our schools? I see no evidence for this so for now I believe the tenure debate is a false debate intended to distract us from the real issues facing our schools—the failure of political and corporate leaders to fulfill the promise of a free and equitable US.
Also, Bill’s graph is likely highly oversimplified and distorting for a reason—to promote his agenda; try Bracey’s Reading Education Research for insight into the inherent distortions found in most data-based graphs and charts.
Lyons’s questions set the stage for yet another major media outlet to perpetuate the corporate and bureaucratic agendas of America’s elite—at the expense of both the debate about education and our schools themselves.
US citizens are falling victim to what scientists are discovering about human nature—we allow our beliefs to drive our commitments even in the face of facts contradicting those beliefs. And the result is discouraging:
And there is where we stand, suckered—suckered by billionaires, suckered by celebrities, suckered by the media (who appear to be simply passing on misinformation because of their own gullibility). And ironically, education is the exact remedy needed to stop this vicious cycle.
I suspect that is why the leading elites in this country are offering the status quo in reform discourse, hoping to keep us uninformed and themselves in charge.
33 Responses to “Wrong Questions = Wrong Answers: Legend of the Fall, pt. IV”
She also will be charged with murder and conspiracy to commit murder.
Around the years there have been a whole of
five coloration options of the air jordan retro 14 built offered,
not such as the much less well-liked reduced-reduce silhouette.
I have seen is the beginning of the embraceable of disclosure of more info by our western government and
a willingness to support more favorably ecological support and friendliness with the voting public.
I just want to say I am very new to weblog and absolutely liked this blog. Very likely I’m going to bookmark your site . You certainly come with very good writings. Thank you for sharing your web-site.
151962 668942Oh my goodness! a great post dude. Thanks a great deal Nevertheless I will probably be experiencing trouble with ur rss . Don
this site is cool!! http://tokumei10.blogspot.jp/ thx read
Very good write-up. I definitely love this site. Thanks!
I’m amazed, I must say. Seldom do I encounter a blog that’s both equally educative and amusing, and without a doubt, you’ve hit the nail on the head. The problem is an issue that too few folks are speaking intelligently about. I’m very happy that I stumbled across this during my search for something regarding this.
After I originally left a comment I seem to have clicked the -Notify me when new comments are added- checkbox and from now on each time a comment is added I get 4 emails with the exact same comment. There has to be a means you are able to remove me from that service? Many thanks!
In the event you are producing over a newspaper’s web site with a specific issue have you been regarded as an internet site columnist or perhaps a blogger? What separates the 2?.
You actually make it seem so easy with your presentation but I find this matter to be actually something that I think I would never understand. It seems too complicated and extremely broad for me. I am looking forward for your next post, I’ll try to get the hang of it!
I’m impressed, I must say. Rarely do I encounter a blog that’s equally educative and amusing, and without a doubt, you have hit the nail on the head. The problem is something which too few folks are speaking intelligently about. Now i’m very happy I stumbled across this in my hunt for something concerning this.
Looking around
I like to browse in various places on the web, regularly I will just go to Digg and follow thru
I went over this web site and I conceive you have a lot of excellent info, saved to my bookmarks (:.
this site is cooooooaaaoooooooooooooooool!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! http://tokumei10.blogspot.jp/ thx read
By having a poor credit score or possibly a low credit standing, it is going to lessen your probability of getting the most effective credit card and loan deals
super real there are a couple of loan cash advance companies that do manage a daily interest, but in the main these are few and far between.
But a smiling visitor here to express the love (:, btw outstanding pattern.
Howdy. I found your blog the use of bing. This is a actually efficiently written document. I will be absolute to bookmark it plus go back to get more information of your beneficial data. We appreciate you the article. We’ll surely come back.
Its like you read my mind! You seem to know a lot about
this, like you wrote the book in it or something.
I think that you could do with some pics to drive the message home a bit, but other than that, this is great blog.
An excellent read. I will certainly be back.
Just attempted this… Initial off I did not utilize the recipe specifically as written. My mix stored being to watery so I extra some far more sugar and considered okay which will do but no… then I reheated the mixture 30 sec intervals to make certain to not burn it and it worked. If you think yours is just not functioning and its not sticking it may be too watery add much more sugar and reheat but make sure to not burn it. Should you possess a potent microwave test ten sec intervals… Honestly up to now so fantastic I burned somewhat of my skin but I like the benefits… did in my encounter. Nxt time am striving my legs.
The numbers are lucky, but only when playing Sudoku. Research your options before you buy your initial deck. You have a circle of people who adore and care for you. We don’t know how issues are going to end up.
This recipe is incredible! I was concerned that the cooking took me nicely more than an hour, however the benefits are fantastic! thanks so much!
Hey, you used to write fantastic, but the last few posts have been kinda boring… I miss your tremendous writings. Past few posts are just slightly out of track! come on!
Hands down, Apple’s app store wins by a mile. It’s a huge selection of all sorts of apps vs a rather sad selection of a handful for Zune. Microsoft has plans, especially in the realm of games, but I’m not sure I’d want to bet on the future if this aspect is important to you. The iPod is a much better choice in that case.
Thanks for these guidelines. Lone fixation I and believe is credit cards providing a 0% interest frequently appeal to consumers in nil degree, immediate say-so and painless on-line balance transfers, on the contrary beware of the number one factor that can void your 0% straightforward streets annual percentage rate and too fling you outdated keen on the humble house rapid.
Yahoo results
While browsing Yahoo I discovered this page in the results and I didn’t think it fit
Dreary Day
It was a dreary day here yesterday, so I just took to messing around online and found
Someone is up to some imaginative fun and frolics. Whatever you say will be taken in the wrong way. The thoughts of the psychic is like a radar, sensing openly without attachment. You will be happiest focusing on practical issues.
commercials funny
[…]we came across a cool web-site which you could delight in. Take a look in the event you want[…]
Tumblr article
I saw someone talking about this on Tumblr and it linked to
painful fails
[…]always a huge fan of linking to bloggers that I adore but really don’t get quite a bit of link really like from[…]
Yahoo results
While browsing Yahoo I discovered this page in the results and I didn’t think it fit
Wikia
Wika linked to this site
News info
I was reading the news and I saw this really cool info
biggest trucks
[…]always a large fan of linking to bloggers that I really like but do not get a good deal of link enjoy from[…]