Writing about standards-driven education reform in her Releasing the Imagination, Maxine Greene explains:
“The wilderness has many aspects, of course; the demons have many faces. What is happening makes me wish, more and more desperately, for authentic dialogue among educators. It is time our own voices are heard with greater clarity, the voices of those who engage with the young in their concreteness and particularity. Children’s and teachers’ stories and journals are breaking through classroom depersonalization. But this change has not broken through into the public space, where we teachers are very seldom asked to testify and are seldom inclined to speak voluntarily for ourselves. . . .Our discussions of standards and curriculum frameworks and outcomes still have not touched seriously upon the matters of our purposes as a society: upon what it means to educate live persons, to empower the young not simply to make a living and contribute to the nation’s economic welfare but to live and, along with others, remake their own worlds.” (p. 170)
And this was during the first decade or so of the current education reform era begun in 1983 with A Nation at Risk. Instead of heeding this warning from Greene, our public and political discourse about education reform has increased calls for standardizing students and continued to marginalize and silence teachers with demands for educators to be objective, nonpolitical, de-unionized, and ultimately obedient.
Simply put, standardized students along with silenced teachers is an un-American education agenda.
Formal education is a pathway to adulthood and autonomy, but learning is an essential human behavior, especially for everyone who embraces freedom and empowerment.
For more than a century, debates about the quality of and needed reform to U.S. public education have been central to our political and public discourse. During the past thirty years, those debates have been primarily focused on accountability driven by standards and testing. The results of three decades of fifty separate experiments in accountability have landed us all in 2011 facing some of the most heated and divisive claims, policies, and protests ever connected with public education.
We persist in calling for higher standards and greater accountability, despite the evidence that this process has never worked. At the center of the continually flawed pursuit of accountability-driven education reform are two prominent errors—(1) ignoring out-of-school factors, primarily related to poverty, as the overwhelming influences on educational attainment and school quality, and (2) forging ahead with standardization instead of seeking a diversity of educational paths for every child.
Education reform discussions tend to fail primarily because they focus solely on in-school reforms, clinging to an idealized view that schools alone can transform society. I want here to focus also on in-school reforms, but with a caveat—U.S. public education will never fulfill its promise as a central institution of a free people if we do not also address social inequities. As Martin Luther King Jr. boldly claimed in 1967, “We are likely to find that the problems of housing and education, instead of preceding the elimination of poverty, will themselves be affected if poverty is first abolished.”
Now, with that established, let’s consider shifting away from a standardization approach to reform and toward a diversity approach to reform by considering the relationship in the U.S. between academics and athletics.
Children learn many lessons not directly taught in the classroom. One of the most powerful lessons students experience is the wink-wink-nod-nod environment surrounding what we have labeled “extracurricular activities” as they compare to the so-called “real world” outside of school—one of the most prominent being athletics.
A few years ago in my introductory education course, I taught a student from England who also played on the university soccer team. One day he told me he found the American attitude toward sports baffling since athletics and academics were not artificially connected in his homeland as they are here through academic requirements for students to play scholastic sports.
As a point of logic, no real connection exists between a young person’s literacy ability or participation in a required ELA class and that same child’s ability to play and access to athletics. We have created a false connection that, in effect, blackmails children into seat time, credentialing, and tolerating academics as a ticket to the athletic field or court.
Many countries—some of which we hold up as ideal education systems—do not link schools and athletics, preferring club sports instead.
We should seriously reconsider academic requirements that are so disconnected from many children’s interest that we have to badger and entice them into compliance. Since the Committee of Ten in the 1890s and throughout the twentieth century, we have wrestled with student apathy and inordinate drop-out rates—all signs that there lacks some perceived value in the traditional and formal education we are offering—but we persist in redesigning the same model over and over, a model that is bureaucratic and standardized.
And we are apt to blame the students themselves, seeking ways to reshape them, to standardize them. Just as we are increasingly de-professionalizing teachers-removing their professional autonomy-and simultaneously also blaming them for educational failures.
But that “real world” mentioned above is not standard at all. In fact, many people spend their lives in professions that are connected, for example, to athletics—coaches, professional athletes, physical education teachers, health and exercise science professors, trainers, physical therapists, and many more. And the same can be said for music, art, theater, and all of those fields we label “extracurricular” and thus outside the accountability and standardization process-those things we do not measure in testing.
And athletes, like artists and actors, can never be accurately evaluated by a standardized test, but we persist with reducing the aspects of education we claim to be most important (literacy and numeracy) to tests decade after decade, again as a central element in our tunnel vision aimed at standardization.
Free and empowered people are not standard, however. Life is not standard, and ultimately, standard is not even a valuable goal or quality when applied to humans or learning-although it is manageable and standard matches our manic faith in efficiency.
Yes, standard is manageable, and here may be the most damning aspect of our pursuit of standardization—Are we more concerned that our children are compliant, that our future workforce is compliant, than being educated, empowered, and even happy?
And is the rise in teacher bashing not more evidence of a call for compliance, silence, and the perpetuation of the exact status quo those in power claim to be confronting?
As long as we focus on standardized paths to adulthood, the answer to both is yes.
The education reform addressing in-school factors that could result in more students succeeding and fewer children choosing to drop-out to avoid the drudgery they associate with formal schooling would be a paradigm shift away from standardization and toward diversity. As Freire argues:
“If studying were not almost always a burden [emphasis in original] to us, if reading were not a bitter obligation, if, on the contrary, studying and reading were sources of pleasure and happiness as well as sources of the knowledge we need to better move about the world, we would have indexes that were more indicative of the quality of our education.” (p. 45)
In short, accountability approaches to education reform are marketing compliance as standards. Demanding that teachers be objective and nonpolitical is yet further proof of the need to silence educators in order to pursue the standardization of America’s children.
We should not be pursuing standardization since we have a century of evidence that it doesn’t work—and logic shows that standard doesn’t match our ideals as a free people—but we should be pursuing challenging opportunities for every child, which in no way stops us from creating a universal public education system that honors and embraces diverse paths to adulthood and autonomy for all children who enter the doorways of our schools.
Privileged adults of this world live diverse and autonomous lives outside of school. The current education reform movement appears more concerned with securing the diverse lives of those privileged than acknowledging the right to an autonomous and diverse life for all children in a society claiming to be free.
Standardization is dehumanizing-and ultimately un-American.
38 Responses to “Standardized Students, Silenced Teachers: The Un-American Education Agenda”
760793 206478How significantly of an significant content material, maintain on penning significant other 842294
I just want to mention I am just all new to weblog and truly savored this web page. Almost certainly I’m want to bookmark your site . You amazingly have beneficial posts. Cheers for sharing your web-site.
718017 897394You must join in a tournament 1st with the greatest blogs on the internet. I will recommend this internet internet site! 189906
this site is cool!! http://tokumei10.blogspot.jp/ thx read
good blog! this site is cool!! http://tokumei10.blogspot.jp/ thx read
Its unusual for me to find something on the internet thats as entertaining and intriguing as what you have got here. Your page is lovely, your graphics are outstanding, and whats more, you use source that are relevant to what you are talking about. Youre certainly one in a million, keep up the good work!
cheap michael kors http://www.apics-triangle.org/mk/cheap-michael-kors.html
Dead written articles , Really enjoyed reading .
michael kors handbags the bay http://www.brontaylor.com/prestatment.asp?mk=michael-kors-handbags-the-bay
In many ways ther
do all michael kors bags have the mk lining http://www.brontaylor.com/prestatment.asp?mk=do-all-michael-kors-bags-have-the-mk-lining
For wordpress there is the wphone which works great for simple themes, how about joomla? any way of updating a joomla website via mobile?.
Would you be interested in exchanging inbound links?
this site is cool!! http://tokumei10.blogspot.jp/ thx read
I love to write creative things such as poetry and short stories, but I don’t know what I would be able to do with the creative writing degree. . . Besides an author or poet, what can I do with a creative writing degree?.
905352 496943There is noticeably a bundle to understand about this. I assume you made specific nice points in functions also. 343469
Good article! We will be linking to this great article on our website.
Keep up the great writing.
It was 1 % less than his April mortgage, which, because of the decline
inside underlying Treasury index, will be within market parameters super real they just would love
your info to get a number of dishonest good reasons.
Thankyou for all your efforts that you have put in this. very interesting information. “If a man writes a book, let him set down only what he knows. I have guesses enough of my own.” by Johann Wolfgang von Goethe.
Thanks considerably pertaining to discussing this specific wonderful persons you really recognize that which you are talking over! Added. Generously also speak with my website Equates to). We will use a hyperlink buy and sell agreement amongst us
It
When some one searches for his essential thing,
so he/she needs to be available that in detail, therefore that thing
is maintained over here.
181042 511444Some genuinely nice and useful info on this website , besides I think the style contains wonderful features. 317530
It can be utilized as an anti-bacterial, so you almost certainly ought to use Anything like that, Vinegar and lime juice will even work.
F*ckin’ remarkable issues here. I’m very happy to peer your post. Thanks so much and i am taking a look ahead to contact you. Will you please drop me a mail?
I know just what you indicate! A good friend and I attempted it for prom and it deffiantly didn’t operate!
I precisely necessary to thank you so significantly yet once more. I do not know the points I would’ve taken care of without these secrets contributed by you regarding this difficulty. It seemed to be a quite frightful crisis for me, but encountering a new well-written tactic you processed it forced me to jump with contentment. Now i am happier for the function and hope you’re aware of an amazing job you happen to be obtaining into educating people by way of your internet weblog. Probably you haven’t come across any of us.
However, both kinds are still beneficial for businesses, whether small,
medium orr big enterprises, and their marketing strategy.
After a comprehensive examination, we reviewed some options.
All of Michael’s sgs were topp chart hits, neverthelss, smooth criminal become popular when ntoduced.
Parties, neighborhood occasions, and even legal matters can see you glow. The Complete Moon opposite your signal can make this a extremely emotional 7 days. Also, try to avoid concerns that can only have a yes or no.
It makes you really feel so numerous things at one time. No one knows for particular exactly where they originated. The cards closest to the death card usually provide clues to its importance in your reading.
what is indicated on the web wtajemniczyć or would be converting from us to the even higher assets plus the trade balance of the United States . You the most important aspects intertwine extremely helpful. Buck less than a dollar is allowed to invest expect that
Thank you for every other great article. Where else may just anybody get that type of info in such a perfect means of writing? I’ve a presentation subsequent week, and I’m at the look for such info.
How many would you like? Venta De Viagra Generico En Mexico refills may not exceed 5. If no refills are indicated on the prescription or if billing for enteral formula, enter 0 in this field.
Tumblr article
I saw a writer talking about this on Tumblr and it linked to
Informative and precise
Its difficult to find informative and accurate information but here I noted
Digg
While checking out DIGG today I found this
Yahoo results
While browsing Yahoo I discovered this page in the results and I didn’t think it fit
Just Browsing
While I was browsing yesterday I saw a excellent article concerning
Wikia
Wika linked to this place
Digg
While checking out DIGG today I noticed this
blog looks without having to hire a
pro to do it for you.and most of all, the best blog hosting sites are the well-established sites that rarely ever experiences down times and errors, and are already popular with many other bloggers for easy community connections and assistance. publish…