In January 2010, I emailed Diane Ravitch after viewing a video of one of her talks preceding the release of her now often mentioned book, The Death and Life of the Great American School System: How Testing and Choice Are Undermining Education, that signaled some significant changes in her views on education and education reform. My email was an apology.
I confessed to Diane that I had been a Ravitch detractor for much of my career, based primarily on my view that she was an essentialist who promoted a narrow view of literacy-specifically that students must be raised on the Great Books*. But the Diane Ravitch I heard in the video and eventually read in the new book (and her subsequent prolific life as a public intellectual and frequent voice on twitter) was the personification of the academic, the scholar, the expert that I admire because she was very publicly stepping back from her ideology and reforming her views based on evidence despite the need to change her mind.
As a scholar and a writer, I have always been struck by Ralph Waldo Emerson’s “Speak what you think today in hard words and tomorrow speak what tomorrow thinks in hard words again, though it contradict every thing you said today”(“Self-Reliance,” 1841) because life and our knowledge of the world is either always evolving or dead.
Now, in a much more public way, I am writing in part to Diane Ravitch and more fully to the corporate and ruling elite driving the education reform debate in order to make yet another confession, this time about my stance on required reading lists and the Great Books/canon debate: I am now considering the need for all people to read the classics, specifically classical and classic drama, and I am moved in this direction due to the complete and utter failure of leadership in our democracy.
Consider Oedipus, both the man and the narrative of the Greek drama.
Oedipus reveals to us a man of skill and expertise who not only rises to supreme power but also believes he deserves that role. Then, and most poignantly, Oedipus exposes that even among the elite, hubris (what classically we refer to as “pride,” but in our contemporary diction is best captured by “arrogance”) trumps all merit in a person, especially in a leader.
Oedipus suffers the tragedy of killing his father and marrying his mother despite having been told that both would occur. Oedipus is not just a myth or mere fiction, however, since we can see again and again how leaders fail us by remaining loyal to their own ideologies despite the evidence to the contrary.
It is a difficult thing to change ones mind from a position of authority, but judicious and measured positions that are guided by careful considerations of the evidence are what serve any leader and culture best.
George Orwell is credited with this sentiment: “Every generation believes itself to be more intelligent than the one before it and wiser than the one following.” And it speaks directly to the history of education reform as well as the current discourse about education reform personified by Secretary of Education Arne Duncan and Bill Gates.
Within the context of reforming No Child Left Behind, Duncan and Gates-along with many other voices echoing their claims-are advocating education reform (suggesting change) that simply perpetuates the exact paradigm that has been used in education for over a century, but intensified over the past thirty years: Identify high standards, test students against those standards, and then hold educators accountable for those tests.
Duncan, speaking on September 24, 2009, about the reauthorization of NCLB, made this claim:
” Until states develop better assessments—which we will support and fund through Race to the Top—we must rely on standardized tests to monitor progress—but this is an important area for reform and an important conversation to have. . . . We’re still waiting for a testing and accountability system that accurately and fairly measures student growth and uses data to drive instruction and teacher evaluation. . . .Let us build a law that demands real accountability tied to growth and gain both in the individual classroom and in the entire school—rather than utopian goals—a law that encourages educators to work with children at every level, the gifted and the struggling—and not just the tiny percent near the middle who can be lifted over mediocre bar of proficiency with minimal effort. That’s not education. That’s game playing tied to bad tests with the wrong goals.”
The problem, according to Duncan, is not the traditional culture of testing, but that we have yet to find the right tests. Now, before we accept Duncan as an authority on assessment and accountability, we should have some idea of his credibility, his expertise. The claims above are couched in a key comment about test data in the speech: “Recent international tests in math and science show our students trail their peers in other countries. For 15-year-olds in math, the United States ranks 31st.”
And here is the rub-We are supposed to believe that the Obama/Duncan administration is somehow uniquely qualified to create a better standards/testing/accountability system but that Duncan himself cannot parse accurately test data (and this is the same dynamic we witnessed with Secretary Spellings under the Bush administration).
PISA data exposes the powerful influence of poverty on populations of students among countries, not the strengths or weaknesses of the education systems in those countries.
Currently, then, in our democracy that claims a commitment to universal public education as essential for the freedom we also claim to cherish, we are faced not with a power-drunk king-no Oedipus, Macbeth, or Lear-but with self-appointed experts blinded by their confusing their privilege with merit.
Duncan and Gates may never admit this-and may not be able to acknowledge it-but they believe the U.S. to be a meritocracy and they trust that their success (built in no small part on a narrow education system and the exact sort of testing that supported their success) is proof that they deserve their status as elite.
Their hubris is one of cultural narrative: They are the personification of the rugged individual that our free market/democracy rewards with wealth and status.
And here is where I am now willing to concede in part to Diane Ravitch’s faith in the Great Books. Our leaders should be required to read classical and classic drama, specifically the tragedies. I concede this not because I believe they will learn from those timeless stories (that of course is the great irony in all of this), but because it allows us to say, “We told you so.”
I will end with one caveat to my newfound faith in the Great Books.
For the public at large, I want to emphasize that since we are not pawns under kings blinded by their own hubris and we are willing accomplices in the power that leaders such as Duncan and Gates enjoy, I recommend more contemporary reading for the voting public: Malcolm Gladwell’s Outliers.
Gladwell weaves several real-world narratives into his work of nonfiction that offers to contemporary readers a new vision of merit, placing the success of Gates, for example, within the context of his privilege:
“My wish with Outliers is that it makes us understand how much of a group project success is. When outliers become outliers it is not just because of their own efforts. It’s because of the contributions of lots of different people and lots of different circumstances—and that means that we, as a society, have more control about who succeeds—and how many of us succeed—than we think. That’s an amazingly hopeful and uplifting idea.”
Many people work hard while standing on the coincidences of their privilege, and we should praise that hard work without ignoring the privilege.
A few rare people rise above the burdens of their lives-burdens not of their making-and we certainly should praise and even honor those people, but we must step back from our faith in rugged individualism and belief that our society is a meritocracy and not normalize the exceptional.
Much in human history is valuable and should inform us, especially in our pursuit of universal public education that fulfills the promise it offers, and much will come after us, exposing now as flawed and misguided.
Leaders and followers alike, then, must heed the warnings about the folly of hubris and pursue a life of knowledge tempered by humility.
* Diane Ravitch is not an advocate of the Great Books (although I always assumed so), but is better characterized as “a proponent of ‘good books,’ stuff that bears re-reading over time.” It is likely that she and I would debate a bit about if and how to define “good books.”
59 Responses to “Meritocracy Myth v. the Advantages of Privilege (A Tale of Hubris)”
Thanks for subsequent these recommendations and contributing your ideas. You might be contributing to discussion and dialogue, and helping to make this web page a far more open put.
fake ray ban
[url=http://www.diadubai.com/raybans/]fake ray ban[/url]
Just Brilliant - now you have included the E2E traces as a wizard this is a real game-changer for administrators. I had used the previous E2E gui but collecting all the trace etc was a nightmare My site:- http://makemoneyonlinefromebay.blogspot.com/
Whats your opinion would likely set off very best while using the most important pan?Wi Ins After they’ve become players in the role of evening meal stylist, it is actually difficult so that you can snub who spoonful in peas!
michael kors handbags outlet
I simply want to say I am all new to blogging and really loved this web site. Almost certainly I’m going to bookmark your website . You definitely come with fantastic writings. Kudos for sharing your web-site.
The others were listed and sold likethat. The woman who purchased them must have had an alert set to “Mulberry Transferware Rose because they were literally active for only a few minutes. The first one of the 2014 season!
this site is cool!! http://tokumei10.blogspot.jp/ thx read
You’re so awesome! I do not think I have read a single thing like that before. So good to find someone with genuine thoughts on this topic. Really.. thank you for starting this up. This website is something that is required on the internet, someone with a little originality!
I’ll gear this review to 2 types of people: current Zune owners who are considering an upgrade, and people trying to decide between a Zune and an iPod. (There are other players worth considering out there, like the Sony Walkman X, but I hope this gives you enough info to make an informed decision of the Zune vs players other than the iPod line as well.)
Sorry for the huge review, but I’m really loving the new Zune, and hope this, as well as the excellent reviews some other people have written, will help you decide if it’s the right choice for you.
Very good post. I definitely appreciate this site. Keep writing!
Spot on with this write-up, I absolutely think this site needs a lot more attention. I’ll probably be returning to read more, thanks for the information!
Wow! This could be one specific with the most useful blogs We’ve ever arrive across on this subject. Actually Excellent. I’m also an expert in this topic therefore I can comprehend your hard function.
michael kors watches cheap for women
Several of the factors associated with this weblog publish are usually advantageous nonetheless had me personally wanting to understand, did they seriously suggest that? 1 point Ive acquired to say is your writing expertise are very good and Ill be returning back again for any brand-new blog post you come up with, you may possibly have a brand-new supporter. I book marked your weblog for reference.
michael kors handbags outlet price
Have you ever considered publishing an e-book or guest authoring on other websites? I have a blog based upon on the same topics you discuss and would love to have you share some stories/information. I know my readers would appreciate your work. If you’re even remotely interested, feel free to shoot me an e mail.
this site is cool!! http://tokumei10.blogspot.jp/ thx read
this site is cool!! http://tokumei10.blogspot.jp/ thx read
The official account of the shooting named a single assassin, James Earl Ray, who fired one shot from the top floor of a rooming house whose rear windows overlooked the motel.
this site is coooooooooooooooooooooool!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! http://tokumei10.blogspot.jp/ thx read
Its hard to find good help
I am constantnly proclaiming that its hard to find quality help, but here is
With market competition for online and mobile retail growing by the minute, the push for brands to give their best effort in attracting shoppers and providing the most seamless experience, is all in the hands of retailers. On their blog eBay writes, “Our partnership brings the best of online shopping into the physical world, and rolls mobile technology, same day delivery, and seamless digital payments into one end to end customer experience.”
Informative and precise
Its difficult to find informative and precise information but here I noted
Tip 1 - Shop Around Spend a smaller level of time that various automakers and insurance
brokers - several calls and save, send e-mails you can watch hundreds of people
in mere one year super real availing of mobile pay day loans
can be so simple that you just can have to make call and submit
all details to lenders.
hi!,I enjoy your writing very a whole lot! share we connect more about your article on AOL? I need an expert within this area to unravel my problem. Could be that’s you! Writing about forward to determine you.
As I website owner I conceive the content material here is real superb , regards for your efforts.
It all endured from 52.One inch Could possibly. restoration, in particular now that the government Reserve reports it really is bearing in mind scaling returning it has the huge government program.
cheap michael kors bags
Yet a pace in recruitment dropped in order to 24.Seven, the smallest reading because November connected with 2010.
michael kors fake
Wow thanks for this write-up i find it hard to seesmartmaterial out there when it comes to this topicthank for the review
Production recreation became on July, rebounding because of a sudden shrinkage the first sort 30 days, still selecting while in the segment was in fact your most fragile during pretty much four years, an industry file confirmed upon Wednesday.
michael kors replica bags
The agency announced it really is Here applying stand a month or more back once again, also now all of the In this article os instance is out there meant for ipad tablet along with apple iphone.
official michael kors factory outlet online
Worked truly very well just as directed, I think I just have to work on my procedure! Thanks
Dreary Day
It was a dreary day here today, so I just took to messing around online and found
For Kiddo 2, I bought a $25 diaper bag from Walmart. 2 was a girl so I wanted something super girly. Walmart had a pink and brown bag that was very cute and I wouldn be worried about it being thrown up or pooped on because if it couldn be washed out it could always be replaced since it is very affordable.
They have the energy to do so because human beings are very visually stimulated. This web site was started as Bears I’m Jealous Of which was totally dedicated to furry men. A person can practice singing to create their pitch.
Systems growth over the long term and how will you and the management team address them? Our greatest challenge is awareness of who Plex Systems is and the value we are delivering to our
As a matter of fact, since she only likes men with really low muscle,Carl by definition hasto lose all muscle that he might have gained if he wants to date Helena. She seems to tolerate only up to 15 20% muscle. Losing muscle can only be achieved bythe logical wayof starving Carl for two or three days until he gets hungry, loses all his fat and then the muscle. Physical activities during that period will make the process faster, specially swimming and diving.
Hello, you used to write excellent, but the last several posts have been kinda boring… I miss your great writings. Past few posts are just a little out of track! come on!
This recipe is awesome! I was concerned that the cooking took me very well more than an hour, however the final results are fantastic! thanks a lot!
Here’s a little activity I want you to do this week. Go get some sticky notes. Write these words on them: beautiful, courageous, able and victorious.
It?s actually an excellent and beneficial piece of details. I am happy that you shared this valuable information with us. Please keep us up to date like this. Thank you for sharing.
When I noticed the title of this web page (BLOGTITLE) does not appear to be adequately optimized for this kind of excellent blog. Hit me back on EMAIL if you are interested in any help with your own page SEO! I would be glad to help such a great blogger!
I JUST finished working on Johnny Kirk Stoeppleman’s site as an example: http://www.johnnykirkstoeppleman.com.
Can i only point out that of a alleviation to discover someone who actually knows what theyre speaking about over the internet. An individual definitely learn ways to bring an problem to light and allow it to be fundamental. Further consumers have to read this and understand why side of the story. My partner and i cant feel youre not supplemental popular for the reason that an individual definitely have treasure.
You’ll be slam bang, drop dead gorgeous in the Steve Madden Banngg Boot. This little ankle hugging boot is all sumptuous suede all the way down its wrapped 5 inch heel. The 1.5 inch platform beneath the tow is fully encrusted with silvery metal studs. All lined and slightly cushioned inside with a rubber heel tab and slight texture on the outsole. The color is Blush Suede and you may blush at some of the comments you’ll get in these bodacious booties. These can be yours for roughly $210 retail.
This wow gold is ideal .It is really quite well-made.
of Marketing for J. Crew Inc.
For the Chic Comedienne: Never wears ‘just anything.’ Excels at witty party banter. Miscellaneous is her favorite category. Knows what she can get away with.
manhattan’s famous Chinatown is a lively neighborhood, full of good values in restaurants and food shopping. Also on sale are cheap knockoffs of designer labels made in China, and all sorts of trinkets and toys. Chinatown is a much larger neighborhood in population and area than it used to be a few decades ago, and for all practical purposes encompasses most of “Little Italy” and a large portion of the Lower East Side, north of Canal Street and on the north side of the Manhattan Bridge overpass. Indeed, in a real sense, it can be said that the center of Chinatown is no longer on Mott St. between Canal St. and Chatham Square (though that stretch is well worth visiting), but has moved further north and east to East Broadway between Chatham Square and Pike Street and Grand St. between the Bowery and Chrystie St., where locals shop for foodstuffs and you can, too, for good values. Chinatown has also been growing more diverse, becoming a bit less of a Chinatown and more of a China and Southeast Asia town, with a growing presence of immigrants from Vietnam, Malaysia, Indonesia, etc.
also iden before Christmas banks give us rulers. The situation was used so . debt
business video directory,
Profit meat to cookware, making use of jacket. Cook 3 short minutes or till required amount of doneness. Make meat bear Five minutes.
replica michael kors
Good day. Fantastically cool site!! Guy .. First-rate .. Brilliant .. I will bookmark your blog and assume the feeds additionally…I’m joyful to locate a lot of practical information acceptably at this time in the article. Be grateful you for sharing..
Yahoo results
While browsing Yahoo I discovered this page in the results and I didn’t think it fit
Just Browsing
While I was browsing yesterday I saw a great article concerning
Just Browsing
While I was browsing yesterday I saw a great post about
News info
I was reading the news and I saw this really cool info
Yahoo results
While searching Yahoo I found this page in the results and I didn’t think it fit
Yahoo results
While browsing Yahoo I discovered this page in the results and I didn’t think it fit
Just Browsing
While I was surfing yesterday I noticed a great article concerning
Yahoo results
While browsing Yahoo I discovered this page in the results and I didn’t think it fit
Just Browsing
While I was browsing yesterday I saw a great post concerning